Which do you prefer?

There's probably not a person on the planet who hasn't heard Billie Jean by Michael Jackson.

A few years ago, Chris Cornell (of Soundgarden fame) did a beautiful, haunting cover of Billie Jean that I instantly fell in love with:




But then this year The Civil Wars did a fantastic cover of Billie Jean as well:



So my question to you is: which do you prefer? I honestly can't decide.